Lincolnshire Chess Association

Minor Counties Competition (2016-17)

MCCU Minor Counties Championship
Position Teams Pl W D L Pts
1 Worcestershire 4 3 0 1 6
2 Lincolnshire 4 3 0 1 6
3 Leicestershire 4 2 0 2 4
4 Warwickshire 4 1 0 3 2
5 Nottinghamshire 4 1 0 3 2

MCCU Minor Counties Championship Match Results
Date Match Result
8 Oct Lincolnshire v Nottinghamshire 13-3
3 Dec Worcestershire v Lincolnshire 8½-7½
21 Jan Warwickshire v Lincolnshire  6½-9½
18 Feb Lincolnshire v Leicestershire 9-7

ECF Minor Counties Championship Match Results
Date Match Result
13 May Essex v Lincolnshire 6½-9½
10 Jun Lincolnshire v Norfolk 8-8
1st Jul Suffolk v Lincolnshire 7½-8½

Lincolnshire v Nottinghamshire

Report from Nigel Birtwistle

Lincolnshire hosted Nottinghamshire in the first match of the new county season at the Lindum Atrium in North Hykeham. We were thrashed by Nottinghamshire in the opening match of last season’s campaign and the Lincolnshire team were hoping to exact some revenge for that defeat. Nottinghamshire were far below full strength and on paper Lincolnshire were the favourites to win. However matches are never won on paper and the match still has to be played. On looking at both line ups it was clear that we held a significant advantage at the top half of the order but that the bottom half was more evenly matched. In fact the match didn’t quite pan out as expected. The Nottinghamshire top boards played very well but their cause wasn’t helped by a total collapse on the lower boards. Lincolnshire won the bottom eight boards, something that we have never done before. So the margin of victory was much larger than it should have been according to the respective player grades but nevertheless still very impressive. Nottinghamshire were weaker than usual and we can be sure that when we play our next match against them they will be seeking retribution. The next match for Lincolnshire will be on Saturday December 3rd when we meet Worcestershire at a neutral venue. Hopefully we will be able to build on the great start that this opening win has given us.

Date: 8/10/16
Venue: North Hykeham
Lincolnshire (Home team) Nottinghamshire (Away team)
Board Colour Name Club Grade Score Name Club Grade
1 W Chris Dorrington Grantham 228 1-0 Robert Richmond West Bridgford 192
2 B Nick Stead Grimsby 199 ½-½ Peter Mercs Gambit 183
3 W Samuel Milson Louth 198 1-0 Brian Thompson West Bridgford 180
4 B Paul Cumbers Grantham 197 ½-½ Glenn Halfpenny Ashfield 171
5 W Nigel Birtwistle Grantham 189 ½-½ Derek Jarvis Ashfield 171
6 B Jason Dilley Grantham 185 ½-½ Geoff Gibson Ashfield 171
7 W Harry Russell Louth 182 1-0 Andrew George Newark 168
8 B J Stuart Williams Grantham 180 0-1 Somton Ukken West Nottingham 167
9 W Peter Cusick Grantham 179 1-0 Onos Kofi-Ofuafor Gambit 167
10 B Stephen Prior Grantham 176 1-0 Anita Somton West Nottingham 165
11 W Joe Kilshaw Grimsby 168 1-0 Alex Combie Newark 164
12 B Denis Georgiou Scunthorpe 165 1-0 Aditya Munshi West Nottingham 164
13 W Keith Palmer Louth 163 1-0 David Levens West Nottingham 160
14 B Alastair Summers Peterborough 156 1-0 Neil Graham Ashfield 158
15 W Ian Burridge Newark 156 1-0 Brian Hayward Gambit 154
16 B Kevin McCarthy Lincolnshire 156 1-0 Drag Sudar Gambit 153
13-3

Worcestershire v Lincolnshire

Report from Nigel Birtwistle

After a thumping win over Nottinghamshire in their first match Lincolnshire were brought crashing back to earth when they went down narrowly against a much improved Worcestershire team by 8½-7½. To be honest Lincolnshire never looked like winning the match as Worcestershire stormed in to a 7-1 lead. With the match almost lost Lincolnshire launched an amazing fightback to give the Worcestershire team some nervous moments but the damage had already been done. The size of the task was too great and eventually Worcestershire secured the vital half point they needed for victory with one game still left in play. Worcestershire thoroughly deserved their victory and Lincolnshire will be hoping for a better performance after Christmas when their next opponents are Warwickshire.

Date: 3/12/16
Venue: Frolesworth Village Hall, Ullesthorpe Road, Frolesworth
Worcestershire (Home team) Lincolnshire (Away team)
Board Colour Name Club Grade Score Name Club Grade
1 W Pavel Besedin Worcestershire 202 1-0 Nick Stead Grimsby 199
2 B Nick Arkell Stourbridge 184 0-1 Samuel Milson Louth 198
3 W John Edge Halesowen 183 1-0 Paul Cumbers Grantham 197
4 B Lee Davis Malvern 181 0-1 Nigel Birtwistle Grantham 189
5 W Peter Kitson Worcester 178 ½-½ Jason Dilley Grantham 185
6 B Dan Lambourne Redditch 177 ½-½ Peter Cusick Grantham 179
7 W Kevin Hurney Worcestershire 177 ½-½ Stephen Prior Grantham 176
8 B Joseph Friar Kidderminster 174 0-1 Murray Smith Lincoln 170e
9 W Brian Turner Malvern 169 1-0 Denis Georgiou Scunthorpe 165
10 B Gregg Dyett Stourbridge 162 0-1 Ivan David Grantham 164
11 W John Wrench Kidderminster 157 1-0 Keith Palmer Louth 163
12 B Stephen Woodhouse Worcestershire 157 1-0 Alastair Summers Peterborough 156
13 W Nigel Towers Redditch 152 0-1 Chris Holt Grantham 156
14 B Gary Jackson Worcestershire 148 1-0 Ian Burridge Newark 156
15 W John Varilone Kidderminster 146 0-1 Andy Hebert Grantham 154
16 B Ray Collett Worcester 145 1-0 Graham Ladds Newark 149
8½-7½

Warwickshire v Lincolnshire

Report from Nigel Birtwistle

Lincolnshire travelled to Syston to play against Warwickshire knowing that a win was desperately needed to keep alive their hopes of qualifying for the national stages of the Minor Counties competition. Warwickshire fielded a much stronger team than the last time that they played Lincolnshire but Lincolnshire still held an advantage in grading on every board bar one. However matches are not won on paper and have to be won over the board. Denis Georgiou set the ball rolling for Lincolnshire when his opponent mixed up his move order early in the opening and walked straight into a kingside haymaker which forced immediate resignation. With the early win on the board Lincolnshire kept their noses in front until the end of the match. The Louth duo of Keith Palmer and Samuel Milson were the last two players to finish. Lincolnshire were 8-6 up at this stage and Keith calmly converted his advantage in to a win to see Lincolnshire over the line. Samuel dug in and managed to draw an inferior looking endgame to make the final score 9½-6½. Lincolnshire had made hard work of winning the match but nevertheless the win was important as they seek qualification to the national stages of the Minor Counties competition. The last match at home against Leicestershire on February 18th will decide our fate.

Date: 21/1/17
Venue: Syston
Warwickshire (Home team) Lincolnshire (Away team)
Board Colour Name Club Grade Score Name Club Grade
1 B Don Mason Shirley 197 ½-½ Chris Dorrington Grantham 228
2 Henrik Stepanyan Sutton Coldfield 194 ½-½ Nick Stead Grimsby 199
3 B Tony Hynes Warwickshire 191 ½-½ Samuel Milson Louth 198
4 W Mark Page Kenilworth 187 1-0 Paul Cumbers Grantham 197
5 B Golam Ali Sutton Coldfield 175 0-1 Nigel Birtwistle Grantham 189
6 W Marcus Walsh South Birmingham 174 1-0 Jason Dilley Grantham 185
7 B Tony Hickey Boldmere St Michael 173 0-1 Harry Russell Louth 182
8 W Simon Smith Warley Quinborne 172 ½-½ Stuart Williams Grantham 180
9 B Keith Escott Sutton Coldfield 171 ½-½ Murray Smith Lincoln E180
10 W Anthony Green Lichfield 170 0-1 Stephen Prior Grantham 176
11 B Mark Cundy Olton 166 0-1 Denis Georgiou Scunthorpe 165
12 W Gary Hope Olton 160 0-1 Ivan David Grantham 164
13 B Keith Thomas Boldmere St Michael 157 0-1 Keith Palmer Louth 163
14 W Jon Turner Warley Quinborne 151 ½-½ Ian Burridge Newark 156
15 B Robert Wallman Olton 148 1-0 Andrew Hebert Grantham 154
16 W Roy Lawrence Sutton Coldfield 138 ½-½ Graham Ladds Newark 149
6½-9½

Lincolnshire v Leicestershire

Report from Nigel Birtwistle

With several regular players unavailable for this fixture I was not very optimistic about our chances of defeating a Leicestershire team who had fielded some strong teams thus far in the campaign. I am very fortunate as a captain to be able to call upon several players who might not necessarily be in the strongest team due to their grading but are almost always willing and able to step in to the breach should they be needed. This was one of those cases and although our resources were stretched to the limit we eventually managed to get sixteen players to the Atrium building at North Hykeham to face our old foes.

To my surprise Leicestershire also had several players unavailable and whilst they out graded Lincolnshire on most of the boards it was not as bad as I had expected. This lifted my spirits and I was more hopeful that we could extend our proud unbeaten run at the Atrium, a venue that we had never lost at since we started playing there way back in 2009.

Although the match was close on the top eight boards Lincolnshire dominated on the bottom eight boards and eventually emerged victorious by a 9-7 scoreline. Only a late fightback by the visitors narrowed the margin of victory and Lincolnshire were always in control of the match.

Notable victories came from two of the last minute replacements, both of them with the black pieces. Veteran Ian McDonald was playing his first match of the season and showed that the old guard are still dangerous opponents for anybody. Scunthorpe’s Steve Lewis was called up at less than 48 hours’ notice and despite having only recently been discharged from hospital he produced a resolute performance which saw him produce a win on debut.

This result means that Lincolnshire moved to the top of the table and are joint MCCU Champions with Worcestershire for the 2016-17 season. The next match for Lincolnshire will be on Saturday May 13th when they will play in the Minor Counties Quarter Final.

Date: 18/2/17
Venue: North Hykeham
Lincolnshire (Home team) Leicestershire (Away team)
Board Colour Name Club Grade Score Name Club Grade
1 B Paul Cumbers Grantham 200 0-1 Shabir Okhai Syston 194
2 Nick Stead Grimsby 199 ½-½ Alan Agnew Ashby 185
3 B Nigel Birtwistle Grantham 196 ½-½ John Denton Melton Mowbray 188
4 W Stuart Williams Grantham 181 ½-½ Brian Galligan Syston 178
5 B Murray Smith Lincoln E180 0-1 Ray Burgess Thurnby 182
6 W Peter Cusick Grantham 171 ½-½ Phil Horspool Wigston 174
7 B Joe Kilshaw Grimsby 167 ½-½ Sean Sheahan Shepshed 174
8 W Denis Georgiou Scunthorpe 164 1-0 Richard Vann Ashby 177
9 B Keith Palmer Louth 162 0-1 Paul Colburn Braunstone 172
10 W Ian Burridge Newark 161 ½-½ Robert Taylor Syston 170
11 B Chris Holt Grantham 160 1-0 Ben Davies Loughborough E170
12 W Kevin McCarthy Lincolnshire 160 1-0 John Mitchell Loughborough 157
13 B Steve Lewis Scunthorpe 157 1-0 Jim Miller Loughborough 158
14 W Alastair Summers Peterborough 156 0-1 Tom Brown Kirby Castlers 148
15 B Ian McDonald Lincoln 146 1-0 Jim Bingham Braunstone 155
16 W Graham Ladds Newark 144 1-0 Mike Salisbury Braunstone 151
9-7

Essex v Lincolnshire

Report from Nigel Birtwistle

Lincolnshire travelled to Peterborough to face old foes Essex in Minor Counties Quarter final on Saturday 13th May. The teams have met in the competition in five out of the last six seasons and although Lincolnshire lost the first three matches we managed to defeat Essex in last season’s quarter final. So the team arrived in a confident mood but everybody was expecting a tough encounter.

Essex had adopted the tactic of playing a lower rated player on the bottom board so that they could field their best players who were both Fide Masters on the top two boards. The match was very close for a while and at one point Essex held a 4-3 lead. However Lincolnshire stormed back to lead 6-5 and a superb win by Chris Dorrington on top board inflicted a hammer blow to our opponents from which they never recovered. Paul Cumbers calmly converted his advantage to give Lincolnshire victory with two games remaining.

It was a fantastic team performance and everybody played their part. We are proving to be a difficult team to beat at this level but we cannot afford to get complacent. Our next match will be against the holders Norfolk at Peterborough on Saturday June 10th. Lincolnshire will be looking avenge their defeat in last year’s final but know that they will have to be at their very best if they are to make it through to finals day for the second year in a row.

Date: 13/5/17
Venue: Peterborough
Essex (Home team) Lincolnshire (Away team)
Board Colour Name Club Grade Score Name Club Grade
1 B Jonathan Rogers Essex 218 0-1 Chris Dorrington Grantham 228
2 Andrew Lewis Manningtree 216 1-0 Nick Stead Grimsby 199
3 B David Sands Essex 199 ½-½ Samuel Milson Louth 198
4 W John Hodgson Essex 192 0-1 Paul Cumbers Grantham 197
5 B David Spearman Essex 194 ½-½ Nigel Birtwistle Grantham 189
6 W Tim Hebbes Essex 194 ½-½ Jason Dilley Grantham 185
7 B Jeff Goldberg Essex 188 ½-½ Harry Russell Louth 182
8 W Ivan Myall Chelmsford 184 ½-½ Stuart Williams Grantham 180
9 B Kevin Bowmer Loughton 188 ½-½ Peter Cusick Grantham 179
10 W Philip Gregory Essex 178 ½-½ Murray Smith Lincoln 179
11 B Ian Reynolds Billericay 175 1-0 Denis Georgiou Scunthorpe 165
12 W Larry Marden Essex  173 ½-½ Ivan David Grantham 164
13 B Elliot Cocks Essex Juniors 162 0-1 Keith Palmer Louth 163
14 W John White Essex 162 ½-½ Chris Holt Grantham 156
15 B Philip Staniland Essex 166 0-1 Alastair Summers Peterborough 156
16 W Jay Sharman Essex 88 0-1 Andy Hebert Grantham 154
6½-9½

Lincolnshire v Norfolk

Report from Nigel Birtwistle

Lincolnshire travelled to Peterborough aiming to reach their second successive Minor Counties Final when they met the holders of the trophy Norfolk. Lincolnshire had narrowly lost in last year’s final to the same opposition and knew that a hard fought match was in prospect if they were to progress to finals day at Warwick.

We were dealt an early blow before the match had even started. I received a telephone call at 11.15am from Denis Georgiou telling me that Joe Kilshaw had been involved in a road traffic accident on his way to the match. Thankfully Joe was unhurt but was unable to play so some quick thinking was needed if I was going to be able to find a substitute at short notice. Denis was travelling with Nick Stead near to Lincoln when he rang me so I was able to divert them to pick up Kevin McCarthy who they literally had to drag out of bed to play. It meant that we didn’t have to default any boards and Kevin was to play an important role in the closing stages of the match as we will see later.

The match was always going to be very tight and started cautiously with several draws. Lincolnshire drew first blood when Nick Stead won a very nice game and by his own admission made amends for his own poor performance in the quarter final. Andy Hebert had played aggressively from the very start against Norfolk captain Antony Hall and was able to convert his material advantage in to an endgame where his pair of bishops and passed pawn proved stronger than his opponent’s lone rook. However Norfolk fought back with two wins and the match was all square again.

Chris Holt produced a controlled performance to edge Lincolnshire in front but then I myself lost after turning down an early draw offer on move fifteen. At this point I was very unhappy with myself for not taking the draw because I knew the extra half point was going to be crucial. Murray Smith held his nerve to grind out a win and after two more drawn games Lincolnshire led by 7½-6½. There were still two games left in play and Lincolnshire needed just a draw from either of these games because the board count would be in our favour in the event of a drawn match. Norfolk need to win both matches to sneak home but were not without hope because they looked to have an advantage in both games.

Norfolk duly won one of the remaining games to level the match. The tension in the air was apparent as players from both teams crowded around the board to watch the last match in play. Kevin McCarthy had the fate of his team in his hands. He knew that a draw was enough to see us home despite being short of time he was able to move quickly and confidently using the 10 second per move increment to build his time up to a more comfortable level whilst at the same time frustrating any attempts that his opponent made to squeeze anything out of a totally drawn position. Eventually his opponent conceded the inevitable draw and although the match was drawn at 8-8 Lincolnshire narrowly edged home on board count by a margin of 39-40.

So the late substitute and Lincolnshire’s most reluctant chess player proved to be the hero of the day. The team showed tremendous fighting spirit and will to win. This was an extremely tough match which frayed a lot of people’s nerves including my own. I am expecting more of the same drama and excitement when we travel to Warwick on Saturday July 1st for the County Championship finals day to where we will play against Suffolk. Hopefully we can overcome the disappointment of the defeat in last year’s final and go one better by lifting the trophy.

Date: 10/6/17
Venue: Peterborough
Lincolnshire (Home team) Norfolk (Away team)
Board Colour Name Club Grade Score Name Club Grade
1 W Chris Dorrington Grantham 228 ½-½ Michael Harris Norfolk 213
2 Nick Stead Grimsby 199 1-0 Stephen Orton Norfolk & Norwich 201
3 W Samuel Milson Louth 198 ½-½ David Lemoir Fakenham 194
4 B Paul Cumbers Grantham 197 ½-½ Ken McEwan Broadland 194
5 W Nigel Birtwistle Grantham 189 0-1 Roy Hughes Broadland 190
6 B Jason Dilley Grantham 185 ½-½ Jonathan Wells North Norfolk 188
7 W Harry Russell Louth 182 ½-½ Gerald Moore Broadland 186
8 B Stuart Williams Grantham 180 ½-½ Dave Dempster Norwich Dons 173
9 W Murray Smith Lincoln 179 1-0 Daniel Frean Broadland 175
10 B Denis Georgiou Scunthorpe 165 0-1 Cor Dekker Wymondham 174
11 W Ivan David Grantham 164 0-1 Steve Moore Norwich Dons 171
12 B Keith Palmer Louth 163 ½-½ Trevor Ansell Fakenham 161
13 W Chris Holt Grantham 156 1-0 Mervyn Hughes Norwich Dons 170
14 B Alastair Summers Peterborough 156 0-1 Terry Turner Norfolk & Norwich 163
15 W Andy Hebert Grantham 154 1-0 Antony Hall Diss 165
16 B Kevin McCarthy Lincolnshire 156 ½-½ Jonathan Burrows Norwich Dons 161
8-8

Suffolk v Lincolnshire

Report from Nigel Birtwistle

After battling their way through two very hard fought matches in the quarter final and semi-final matches Lincolnshire returned to Warwick to play the Minor Counties final for the second successive year. Lincolnshire were looking to put behind them the defeat they suffered in last year’s final but knew that their opponents Suffolk would provide a stern test and a very difficult match was in prospect. I had some very difficult decisions to make in selecting a side for the final. Almost every player was available to play so unfortunately some players were going to have to miss out if I was to keep the average rating of our team under 180 which was required by the rules of the competition. Eventually I settled for a very strong line up in which the average grade of our team was 179.93. Suffolk by comparison weighed in at exactly 180.

I had seen that Suffolk had been fielding a lower rated junior player on board 16 in their previous matches which enabled them to strengthen their middle to lower order. I decided to follow suit and brought in the very promising young Grimsby player Arya Parnian to the team for his first match of the season. Suffolk fielded International Master Alan Merry on board 1 which was going to be a difficult test for Chris Dorrington and this proved to be a crucial encounter.

Lincolnshire drew first blood after a couple of hours of play when Harry Russell led his opponent into a tricky variation of the Najdorf Sicilian and drew a fatal mistake from his opponent to score us our first point. Several draws followed before the Grantham duo of Chris Holt and Ivan David won their games to put us three points in front. However Suffolk fought back with two victories to narrow the deficit.

By his own admission Samuel Milson has not been at his best for much of this season. In last year’s final he also suffered a horrible defeat. But this time he was able to put all his woes behind him and put together a crushing Kingside attack which his opponent was unable to withstand. Going in to the closing stages of the match Lincolnshire were leading by 7½-6½ with two games left. I knew that the board count was not going to favour us this time if the match was drawn so we needed another point from somewhere.

Chris Dorrington had won a pawn in the middlegame but was now faced with a difficult queen and pawn endgame. The spectators looked on nervously as Chris slowly and methodically increased his advantage. He was totally unfazed by the pressure however and won a couple more pawns before forcing the exchange of queens. A pawn race ensued with both players promoting to a new queen but Chris had seen further and a forced sequence enabled him to force yet another queen exchange which forced his opponents resignation. Lincolnshire had won the match!

Suffolk won the last match in play to make the final score 8½-7½. The match had been a particularly bloodthirsty encounter with six decisive results on the top eight boards. For me personally it had been another nerve racking experience. Since I took over the captaincy in 2009 Lincolnshire had been knocked out in the quarter finals twice and had been beaten in three semi-finals as well as last year’s final. I had begun to wonder if we would ever win the Minor Counties competition under my captaincy but the players have remained incredibly loyal and have shown tremendous determination to bounce back from these setbacks.

This was an unforgettable day in the history of Lincolnshire chess. The only time that Lincolnshire had won the Minor Counties competition previously was way back in 1989. There were three survivors from that team that played in the final this year. Myself, Nick Stead and Keith Palmer were all much younger then but all of us agree that the common factor binding the legends of 1989 to the present day team is a fantastic team spirit. After the presentation of the trophies the team went out for a meal in Leamington Spa to celebrate our victory.

Now that we have finally achieved our goal what is next for the team? We can try and defend the Minor Counties trophy or maybe we can be brave and opt to enter the Open section for one season instead. This would be a very tough proposition if we decide to mix it with the big boys for a season. Whatever we decide to do I know that I can rely on the continued support of such a dedicated and enthusiastic group of players and it will be my pleasure to continue to captain the team if asked to do so.

Photo gallery

View Games

Date: 1/7/17
Venue: Warwick
Suffolk (Home team) Lincolnshire (Away team)
Board Colour Name Club Grade Score Name Club Grade
1 W Alan Merry Bury St Edmunds 232 0-1 Dorrington, Chris Grantham 228
2 Adam Taylor Suffolk 206 ½-½ Nick Stead Grimsby 199
3 W David Spence Suffolk 207 0-1 Samuel Milson Louth 198
4 B Edmund Player Bury St Edmunds 201 1-0 Paul Cumbers Grantham 197
5 W Graham Moore Ipswich 195 1-0 Nigel Birtwistle Grantham 189
6 B Shaun Munson Ipswich 195 1-0 Jason Dilley Grantham 185
7 W Ian Wallis Ipswich 187 0-1 Harry Russell Louth 182
8 B Nicholas Savage Ipswich 180 ½-½ Stuart Williams Grantham 180
9 W Silas Peck Ipswich 176 ½-½ Stephen Prior Grantham 176
10 B Alexander Peters Bury St Edmunds 177 ½-½ Murray Smith Lincoln 179
11 W Leon Burnett Suffolk 171 ½-½ Peter Cusick Grantham 179
12 B Timothy Lunn Ipswich 174 ½-½ Joe Kilshaw Grimsby 168
13 W John Feavyour Saxmundham 166 0-1 Ivan David Grantham 164
14 B Andrew Shephard Ipswich 153 1-0 Keith Palmer Louth 163
15 W Ed Kirkham Felixstowe 150 0-1 Chris Holt Grantham 156
16 B Jaden Jermy Bury Knights 110 ½-½ Arya Parnian Grimsby 136
7½-8½